FIXTURESNo upcoming fixtures — check back soon.
FORUM / RUGBY /  AB rugby in trouble?

AB rugby in trouble?

Started by Plum5 REPLIES31 VIEWS· 24 Sept 2026, 11:59
SHAREXFACEBOOKWHATSAPPTELEGRAMREDDITLINKEDIN
Plum
PlumCaptain22,106 posts
24 Sept 2026, 11:59
#1
24 Sept 2026, 11:59#1

The EggChaser vid below pretty much lays the problem out in enough detail.

They're attempting to fund a fully professional league with 5 million customers, of which more and more are switching to NRL.

They're investing in the ladies' game and there doesn't appear to be consensus on whether that'll show commercial benefit down the road.

One of the proposed solutions is to end SR, effectively destroying the rugby partnership between Australia and NZ, and to instead focus on a domestic league.

Tough times and big decisions.

One thing is clear, they have clowns running the show.

sharkbok
Captain23,420 posts
sharkbok24 Sept 2026, 10:38

They made a mistake by cutting South Africa from Super Rugby. Australia doesn't have the depth to field a few competitive teams.

The main problem the All Blacks have is their tight 5, none of which would make a World XV team

BE
Beeno1Captain40,442 posts
24 Sept 2026, 13:54
#2
24 Sept 2026, 13:54#2

quite a few years ago I said that South Africa leaving the super Comp would resulted in an lesser competition that would negatively effect the wee abs. Next I pointed out there would be a significant financial cost. Thirdly I noted more PI were playing in Australia and Europe. I was years ahead of the curve once again.
Had NZ not tried to shaft us with bent refs, trying to change rugby rules that would take away or weaken Bok advantages ( an ongoing effort as we saw with the Depower the scrum campaign launched by Dave Renee) and not giving us a fair financial deal we may still be suffering in the old Super Comp.
I said it would be better to go North. And so it has proved. More money, better travel and good competition for our sides that helped us develop test level players.
Many oaks were not at all happy for us to go north. Bcs was very worried as well.
Now Plumpster has had the light go on. Better late than never Plumpster.

Plum
Captain22,106 posts
Plum24 Sept 2026, 13:51

umm...Beeno, you will find that i have made numerous posts about being glad we went North, and went Into quite a bit of detail in them about all the reasons I felt it was a good move.

What you'll also find is that I produced a chart, some years ago already, to show the AB win graph since we left SR.

You area not early my man.

Plum
Captain22,106 posts
Plum24 Sept 2026, 13:55

@Plum read this thread, Beezi. There are more too...

link text

KI
kingcornPro3,872 posts
24 Sept 2026, 15:15
#3
24 Sept 2026, 15:15#3

I think we went through this a few times on this board. I love the old Super 12, but always felt it favoured NZ as they had 5 teams, SA 4 and Aus 3. They also managed to get fewer trips on the road and they broke the understanding that it would be provinces, not franchises, they also influenced the rugby rules heavily by having paddy o brien, former ref as the main person on the rugby rules panel.

A fair system would be equal matches, but now you add Australie, the Brumbies, Waratahs and Reds were some of the toughest teams to play against. It was a very difficult completion and near test quality.

I blame Australia for expansion and conference nonsense.

I'm not a fan of the URC and it is starting this week with no boks in the teams as Rassie is milking the test window.

Then, the European comp is fragmented. France is the only country with a proper domestic, cash rich competition.

Agree on woman in rugby, why make them refs, why have female commentators why invest so much in the female game when they would far rather watch the kardashians than go to a rugby game and support the ladies. This is what DEI does.

Rugby is screwed and that goth that fucked up Australian rugby.

Rugby will never make real money but it is about a core group of fans, that love the game and very knowledgable.

What world rugby should have done was to build a South American regional coipition. Chile, Uruguay, Argentina, Brazil. The US can't get fans or teams to stay around long enough to become a proper comp.

Eastern Europe had massive potential, Georgia, Romania, Serbia and Russia could form their own league.

But groups like Super rugby and URC are forcing their expansion for audience numbers and not about developing the game locally

— END OF THREAD —

More from Rugby

More news